He currently plays for New York City FC, wearing the number 71 shirt. He plays primarily as a Midfield.

His most recent move was a from New York City Team B to New York City FC on 2027-01-01.

Across 3 appearances in the United States Major League Soccer 2025, Peter Molinari registered 0 goals and 0 assists, while completing 0 key passes out of 0 total passes with a passing accuracy of -.